← Back to the full issueComing soon visits
Allocate

US tariffs change. Who pays the difference?

Listen to the analysis

AIVoices and adaptation generated with NotebookLM; video illustrations generated with AI. Automatic transcription may contain errors. Historical analysis of issue 006, cut off 28 September 2026; no current legal update or certification of compliance.

Download captions

Read the transcript
This audio adaptation was generated with Notebook LM.
Imagine you are at a group dinner.
You've all like agreed to split the bill
based on the menu prices, right?
But mid meal, the restaurant manager
just tax on a mandatory 20% surcharge.
- Oh, that sounds like an absolute nightmare.
- Right.
The check arrives and total chaos breaks out.
Why?
Because your agreement with your friends,
your contract basically was totally silent
on who covers a sudden unexpected tax.
- Yeah, and nobody wants to pay that extra cash.
- Exactly.
Well, welcome to today's Deep Dive,
curated specifically for you.
We are analyzing Law Right Newsletter 006,
specifically an article with an editorial date
of September 28th, 2026,
titled US Tariffs Change, Who Pays the Difference?
- It's a really fascinating piece.
- It really is.
Our mission here is to extract the practical realities
of how shifting international tariffs
impact business contracts.
You know, helping you cut through the noise
of all those geopolitical headlines.
- Which is exactly why the newsletter's fictional scenario
is, well, pretty much every supply chain manager's
worst nightmare right now.
- Oh, absolutely.
Remind me what the scenario was again.
- So there is this Belgium manufacturer
who suddenly gets hit with a surcharge request
from their US partner.
And the partner is citing new customs duties.
- Uh-huh.
- And the core problem here is that the original quote
they agreed on just, you know, lump the product price
and the import charges all together.
- Ah, so they didn't separate the menu price
from the manager's surprise tax.
So how do we figure out who is actually legally on the hook?
- Well, to figure out if that US surcharge is valid,
we have to look at the legal baseline
on both sides of the ocean.
Let's start with the European side first.
- Okay, sounds good.
- So back on July 1st, 2026,
the European Commission implemented a framework
setting a 15% ceiling for most EU exports.
- Got it.
But there were exceptions, right?
- Yeah, exactly.
Carved out specific exceptions and separate treatments
for certain steel and aluminum derivatives.
- Wait, let me just pause you there for a second.
The newsletter makes a really big deal
about this being an institutional explanation.
- Yes, that is a huge distinction to make.
- So what does that actually mean
in plain English for you, listener?
- Well, think of an institutional explanation
as like a broad policy guideline.
I mean, it's the overall rule book,
but it is not an individual customs determination.
- Meaning it's not the specific receipt
handed to you at the border based on your exact items.
- Right.
You can't just wave the broad rule book at customs
and expect them to clear your crate.
You need the actual determination
for your specific goods.
- Makes total sense.
And you know, when we talk about these rule books
taking effect, timing is everything.
- It really is.
- Because the newsletter mentions a council release
from June 25th, 2026.
It was about adopting two new regulations
for these tariff commitments.
- Yeah, and that's a crucial procedural step,
but here is where businesses often trip up.
- Oh.
- How so?
Well, the council announced those rules in June 25th, right?
But they didn't actually kick in that day.
- Oh, they didn't.
- No, entry into force only happens the day
after they were officially published
in the EU's official journal.
Like a press release doesn't make it legally binding.
Only the formal publication does.
- Wait, wait, let me challenge that timeline
for a second just based on recent news.
- Sure, go for it.
- We've all seen the massive headlines
about the Supreme Court ruling
in learning resources versus Trump.
- Ah, yes, the big one.
- Right, so the court held that the president
can't impose tariffs under IEEPA.
- Correct.
- So doesn't that automatically erase the invoice
or charge for our fictional Belgian manufacturer
like problem solved?
- You know, it seems like it should, but it doesn't.
And this is a really massive misconception out there.
- Really, why is that?
- So the Supreme Court indeed held that IEEPA
doesn't authorize the president to impose tariffs,
but the opinion explicitly distinguishes other authorities.
- Oh, like what kind of authorities?
- Most notably, section 232.
Plus, you have to keep your source classes distinct.
I mean, a release is not a judgment,
a draft is just a proposal,
and complaints only contain allegations.
- Ah, I see.
- So the ruling definitely doesn't remove all US tariffs.
- Exactly.
- And most importantly, that ruling
does not guarantee a contractual refund
for the Belgian manufacturer.
- Because the Supreme Court
isn't managing their specific invoice, right?
- Precisely.
Your contract is still your true baseline.
- So bringing this all together,
what is the ultimate practical takeaway
for you, the listener,
if you are managing international deals right now?
- I mean, the biggest takeaway is you must separate
the official customs treatment of a transaction
from the contractual allocation of its cost.
- Got it.
So what should they actually do on Monday morning?
- You must verify the product classification,
the origin of the goods, and the exact date.
And definitely do not promise a customer reimbursement
solely because of that American judgment.
- Right, don't just jump the gun
based on a headline you saw.
- Never do that.
For your next order,
you really need to negotiate an understandable mechanism
that explicitly covers triggering events
and the exact evidence required.
- So no more vague dinner receipts.
- You really need to agree on who covers
the surprise taxes before you even sit down at the table.
- That is the best way to handle it, yeah.
- Which leaves you with a final thought to mull over.
If global trade agreements cross multiple borders
and rely on unpredictable legal rulings,
how can modern businesses effectively
future-proof their contracts when the baseline itself is constantly moving.

A trade agreement provides a framework. Your product and contract determine what needs checking next.

Areas of lawInternational tradeContractsCustoms
Keywords#United States#tariffs#price#imports

Case statusResearch closed on 28 September 2026 · check for changes before taking a decision.

Conceptual illustration created with AI assistance for Law Right; no documentary scene or real person.
Image and licence. Conceptual illustration created with AI assistance for Law Right; no documentary scene or real person.

01

One trade framework, several possible outcomes

In its presentation updated on 27 July 2026, the Commission describes the EU–US framework as implemented from 1 July. It reports a 15% ceiling for most European exports, with exceptions and particular treatment of some steel and aluminium derivatives. Most does not mean all: this institutional summary does not establish the duty payable on a specific product. [1]

On 25 June, the Council announced final adoption of two regulations implementing tariff commitments, with safeguard and suspension mechanisms. Its press release still referred to forthcoming publication in the Official Journal. It establishes a procedural step; it should not alone be treated as proof of the date on which every measure entered into force. A particular transaction requires the applicable texts. [2]

02

A court ruling does not erase every invoice

On 20 February 2026, in Learning Resources, Inc. v. Trump, the US Supreme Court concluded that IEEPA did not authorise the challenged tariffs. The relevant passage of the Court’s opinion was consulted. That conclusion concerns this legal basis; it does not mean that all US tariffs have disappeared. Cornell’s explanatory commentary helps place the judgment in context but does not replace it. [3,4]

Separate the customs treatment of the transaction from the contractual allocation of its cost. Before discussing a surcharge, have the product classification, origin, relevant date and asserted regime clarified. Request supporting records for the shipment concerned. An average, an announced ceiling or the rate for a similar product cannot replace that assessment. Keep unresolved points visible until they have been checked.

Then examine pricing and adjustment clauses. Who must substantiate an additional charge? Which date provides the baseline? Are decreases treated like increases? Does the agreement address a possible refund? These questions prepare the assessment. They do not presume an automatic right to renegotiate or an automatic entitlement to suspend delivery. Those conclusions would need their own factual and legal analysis.

03

The Law Right approach: compare an invoice with a clause

  1. Take a specific order and assemble the quotation, contract, shipment documents and the partner’s calculation. Ask the appropriate specialist to verify the customs treatment. Retain the date of that verification: the answer can depend on when importation occurred and which regime then applied. Record any missing documents that prevent a reliable calculation.
  2. For the next order, negotiate an understandable mechanism covering the triggering event, supporting evidence, notice period and allocation of a change. Have the effects of a dispute and a potential refund examined too. A balanced arrangement can be negotiated commercially; it cannot simply be assumed to exist in an earlier contract. Make sure the agreed process is workable for both teams.
  3. Do not promise a customer reimbursement solely because of the American judgment. The importer’s identity, procedure and commitments between the parties need separate examination. Full legal texts and the product’s regime remain to be checked before any individual conclusion. This article supplies a working method, not a guaranteed tariff or an assurance of recovery.
A WORLD ON CONDITIONS · 03

A contract crosses several borders.

Identify the parties, goods or services and countries involved.

Explanatory schematic: illustrative relationships, not a measurement of dependencies or a legal conclusion.
→

Before allocating a cost change, establish the duties applicable to the shipment and what the contract provides.

Sources and verificationOpen the sources +

Watch the story

AIVoices and adaptation generated with NotebookLM; video illustrations generated with AI. Automatic transcription may contain errors. Historical analysis of issue 006, cut off 28 September 2026; no current legal update or certification of compliance.

Download captions

Read the transcript
This video adaptation was generated with Notebook LM.
Okay, let's jump right into this explainer.
We're looking at a super relatable scenario straight out of the law right newsletter,
specifically Article 2 from their September 28, 2026 edition.
Picture this, a Belgian manufacturer suddenly gets hit with a surcharge request
from their American partner, citing new customs duties.
The catch, their original quote was, well, a bit vague,
and it didn't clearly separate the product price from the import charges.
Then, to make things even more confusing,
a news headline pops up suggesting a tariff reduction might actually be on the horizon.
So who actually eats the cost of that initial increase?
And if there is a decrease, who gets to pocket the savings?
As we're gonna see, a catchy news headline definitely can't answer either of those questions for you.
To figure this out, we've got a quick four-part agenda today.
One, the EU-US trade framework.
Two, the Supreme Court ruling.
Three, customs versus contractual allocation.
And four, preparing for future orders.
The EU-US trade framework, taking a look at those macro-level institutional actions.
We really need to look at how this all unfolded back in 2026.
It's kind of like a giant puzzle.
It kicked off with a massive judicial decision from the US Supreme Court in February.
Then jumping across the Atlantic, we saw the Council of the EU put out a press release in June.
And finally, the European Commission's trade framework officially took effect in July.
Laying it out chronologically like this really helps us see how policy and the legal reality were shifting in real time.
Let's zoom in on that June event for a second.
The Council's June 25th press release formally announced the adoption of two regulations dealing with tariff commitments.
But, and this is a huge but, pay attention to the mechanics here.
The release specifically noted that the actual entry into force wouldn't happen until the day after they were published in the official journal.
You see, a press release is just a procedural step.
It is absolutely not proof of the exact date a measure became legally binding.
And how did the European Commission describe the resulting framework?
Well, effective July 1st, 2026, it established a general 15% ceiling for most European exports.
But notice the exceptions.
They explicitly carved out separate treatment for certain steel and aluminium derivatives.
So the magic word here is most.
Most definitely does not mean all.
Here's the absolutely crucial takeaway.
An institutional explanation or a press release from the Commission gives you a broad framework, sure.
But it does not establish the individual customs determination or the specific duty you have to pay for your particular product on a given day.
These summaries are great for understanding the overall climate,
but they simply can't replace the hard legal texts required for an actual real world transaction.
The Supreme Court ruling, where we unpack the judicial reality.
OK, February 20th, 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court hands down its opinion in Learning Resources v. Trump.
And they made a very specific conclusion regarding the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, commonly known as IEEPA.
The court explicitly held that IEEPA did not authorize the president to impose the challenge tariffs.
Now, for a lot of importers, reading that headline felt like an instant massive win.
But hold on, we really need to understand the boundaries of this ruling.
Yes, it addresses that specific legal basis.
It also distinguishes other authorities, like Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act.
But you know what it absolutely does not do?
It does not wipe out all U.S. tariffs.
And it definitely doesn't magically guarantee a contractual refund for every invoice a manufacturer has paid.
Just because one legal basis disappears, it doesn't mean the whole tariff system vanished into thin air.
And you know how it is. After a ruling like this, the analysis just floods in.
Secondary sources, like Cornell's explanatory commentary, are fantastic for putting the judgment into context.
But a news release or an explanatory commentary is not the judgment itself.
When your business decisions and contract allocations are on the line, you always, always have to check the full legal texts.
Customs vs. contractual allocation.
Let's look at the micro-level application.
The law-right newsletter offers some incredibly grounded practical advice here.
Before you get into a heated argument with your business partner over a sudden surcharge,
you absolutely must separate the customs treatment of the transaction
from the contractual allocation of those costs.
First things first, get your facts straight.
You need to completely clarify the product classification, the country of origin,
the exact date of importation, and the specific regime applied.
Oh, and always request a supporting customs records for that specific shipment. No exceptions.
Because here's the thing. You can't just swap in a general average rate
or rely on an announced ceiling from some press release.
Or even use the rate you got for a similar product last month.
Customs is exact. It's a strict assessment of a specific shipment.
Any unresolved points have to stay visible and flagged
until they are completely checked against the actual texts.
So once you've nailed down the exact customs reality,
then you can look at your pricing and adjustment clauses.
And you've got to ask some tough questions.
Like, who is actually required to substantiate the additional charge?
What specific date is the baseline for a price change?
Are decreases handled the exact same way as increases?
Does your agreement even mention a potential refund?
Listen, just because a tear of changes doesn't mean you automatically get to
renegotiate your contract or pause your delivery.
Those actions require their own separate factual and legal analysis.
Finally, section four. Preparing for future orders.
Let's talk about grounded practical actions.
The article outlines a very disciplined three-step method for handling specific orders.
Step one, assemble everything.
I mean the original quotation, the contract, the shipment docs,
and your partner's calculation.
Step two, get a specialist to verify the customs treatment,
specifically based on the exact date of importation
and the regime that applied on that precise day.
And step three, strictly record any missing documents
that get in the way of a reliable calculation.
Because if you can't calculate it reliably,
you certainly can't allocate the cost fairly.
Going forward, commercial teams really need to step up
and proactively negotiate balanced, understandable mechanisms for future orders.
You can't just assume your old contract has you covered.
Your new contracts need to spell out triggering events,
dictate the required evidence, set clear notice periods,
and explicitly state exactly how any cost changes will be allocated.
On top of that, you need to think about what happens in a dispute
and how potential refunds will be handled if tariffs are retroactively dropped.
Now this is a massive takeaway, so pay close attention.
Do not, under any circumstances,
promise a customer a reimbursement solely because you read a headline
about that American Supreme Court judgment.
The specific identity of the importer, their internal procedures,
and the unique bilateral commitments between your two parties
all of that requires its own entirely separate legal examination.
Ultimately, this explainer gives us a working method,
not a magically guaranteed tariff or a promise of getting your money back,
which leaves us with a pretty critical question to chew on as we wrap up.
While international trade agreements provide the big-picture macro framework,
is your specific micro-level contract truly prepared
to handle sudden tariff changes without absolutely destroying your profit margins?
Think about it.
It's a question everyone navigating international business today
absolutely has to ask themselves.
Read the full issue

Law Right library

Return to every issue.

Each new issue expands the collection without replacing what came before.

Your network may not share an email address

Secure sign-in will become active once the app has been approved by the network. For this first issue, enter your email below. Your network choice is recorded only as the source; nothing is posted to your account.

LexiTalk to Lexi